Erie County, NY vs St. Johns County, FL
Property Tax Rate Comparison 2025
Quick Answer
Erie County, NY: 1.76% effective rate · $5,621/yr median tax · median home $319,394
St. Johns County, FL: 0.89% effective rate · $2,060/yr median tax · median home $231,500
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Metric | Erie County, NY | St. Johns County, FL | National Avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Effective Tax Rate | 1.76% | 0.89% | 1.06% |
| Median Annual Tax | $5,621 | $2,060 | $2,778 |
| Median Home Value | $319,394 | $231,500 | $268,728 |
| Population | 954,236 | 274,119 | — |
Erie County, NY
- Effective Rate
- 1.76%
- Median Annual Tax
- $5,621
- Median Home Value
- $319,394
- Population
- 954,236
St. Johns County, FL
- Effective Rate
- 0.89%
- Median Annual Tax
- $2,060
- Median Home Value
- $231,500
- Population
- 274,119
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the property tax difference between Erie County and St. Johns County?
Erie County, NY has an effective property tax rate of 1.76% with a median annual tax of $5,621. St. Johns County, FL has a rate of 0.89% with a median annual tax of $2,060. The difference is 0.87 percentage points.
Which county has higher property taxes, Erie County or St. Johns County?
Erie County, NY has the higher effective property tax rate at 1.76% compared to 0.89%.
How do Erie County and St. Johns County compare to the national average?
The national average effective property tax rate is 1.06%. Erie County is above average at 1.76%, and St. Johns County is below average at 0.89%.